Review process

The review process of the articles is done confidentially and the name of authors for the reviewers and the reverse is not mentioned.

Reviewing the articles at first is conducted with respect to the standards of the journal and then is sent to the editor-in-chief.

If the article content is congruent with the journal issues of interest and if it entails innovation and practical implications for further achievement of journal’s goals, it is sent to the reviewers, otherwise, it would be rejected with non-review reasons.

Approved-by-editor articles are sent for three reviewers and reported to the editor if it is scored with two positive points.

The ultimate decision for acceptance or rejection of the article is taken by editor-in-chief and board members.

Peer Review Criteria 

• Using proper methods in research implementation
• Presenting novel findings and linking them to the current knowledge of the field.
• Comprehensiveness and precision in the article
• Quantity and volume
• Quality of references
• Academic quality of findings and using proper instruments for assessment and measurements
• Valid analysis of findings and conclusion
• Ease of writing and establishing good understanding of research studies
• Presenting total research issues for replicability
• Congruency between topic or purpose and journal categories
• Acceptance criteria (rejected with non-review reasons):
• Authenticity
• Subject conformity with journal content
• Innovation of the study and novelty of findings
• Applicability of the findings
• Implementing valid and novel methods.
• Using proper methods for reporting findings and correct statistics
• Implementing academic methods for article writing
• Observing the template of journal for article submission

Ahmadreza Movahedi

Rasool Zeidabadi

Mahdi Shahbazi

Shahzad Tahmasebi Boroujeni

Zahra Salman

Mohammad Reza Ghasemian Moghadam

Alireza Bahrami

Rosa Rahavi

Abdoli, Behrooz

Abdolrahman Chapari, Shima

Abdoshahi, Maryam

Aghababa, Alireza

Aghapoor, Seid Mehdi

Aghdasi, Mohammad Taghi

Ahar, Saeid

Ahmadi, Malek

Arab Ameri, Elahe

Arsham, Saeed

Badami, Rokhsareh

Bagherzadeh, Fazlollah

Bahrami, Alireza

Balali, Marzieh

Dana, Amir

Daneshfar, Afkham

Eslami, Rasol

Estiri, Zahra

Farsi, Alireza

Fathi Rezaei, Zahra

Ghadiri, Farhad

Ghasemi, Abdollah

Ghayour, Mahbobeh

Gholami, Amin

Ghorbanzadeh, Behrouz

Hatami, Farzaneh

Hemayattalab, Rasul

Homaninan, Davood

Kashani, Vali Ollah

Kashi, Ali

Kordi, Hasan

Lotfi, Gholamreza

Maleki, Farzad

Meshkati, Zohreh

Mohammadzade, Hasan

Mokaberian, Monireh

Moteshareie, Ebrahim

Mousavi, Seyed Kazem

Movahedi, Ahmad Reza

Naeimi Kia, Malihe

Naghdi, Naser

Namazi Zade, Mahdi

Nazemzadegan, Hossain

Pashabadi, Ali

Rafei, Mehdi

Rafiee, Saleh

Saberi Kakhaki, Alireza

Saemi, Esmaeel

Salehi, Hamid

Shahabi Kaseb, Mohammadreza

Shahbazi, Mehdi

Shahbazi, Sohila

Shahrzad, Neda

Shamsipour, Parvaneh

Sheikh, Mahmoud

Shojaei, Masoumeh

Taheri-Torbati, Hamid-Reza

Tahmasbi, Farshid

Tahmasebi Broojeni, Shahrzad

Talebi, Rohollah

Vaez Mmousavi, Seyed Mohamad Kazem

Yaali, Rasol

Zarezade, Mahshid